to be fair for the human like designs do the ponies look like realistic ponies? I don't think so...While I do not agree with the designs I wouldn't judge them for being too unrealistic there are some things we all would do different but don't be too harsh we havent seen it in action yet. I say its more anthro myself anyway. Don't judge it before you watch it if all the bronies did that would we have the fandom we have today? Just beacause its not what you want it to look like doesn't mean it will be an attrocity vomited up by a rainbow like most are complaining about not to mention both are fan designs you have there watch the trailer The movie will not become a show and it won't replace the main one
Herp the derp. I forgot to comment on the actual art. You did an awesome job on the human Twilight Sparkle; she's pretty much a perfect interpretation of the character. Good use of color theory on the shirt; it fits perfectly even though it's not a color normally associated with her.
But the whole thing that makes MLP:FiM so awesome is that it's a show about ponies that doesn't stink. I couldn't watch a version with them as anime girls; it would be too creepy if I found a member of the cast attractive.